Access Dots displays camera and microphone activity indicators on Android
Access Dots is a free application for Google's Android operating system that displays camera and microphone activity indicators on the screen.
Apple unveiled a new version of its iOS operating system this year, and one of the new features of the operating system introduced activity indicators for cameras and microphones. Devices that run iOS 14 display green and orange dots in the top right corner of the screen when there is camera or microphone activity. The main idea behind the feature is to inform users when an application uses the microphone or the camera of the device.
While that is usually wanted by the user, e.g. when the camera application is opened or when a voice call is made, it could also happen that apps use the camera or the microphone covertly (after having given permission to them once).
Google introduced persistent indicators in Android 9 when devices need access to the camera or microphone, but these are easy enough to overlook or turn off.
Access Dots implements the privacy feature that Apple introduced in iOS 14 for Android devices. The app needs accessibility privileges as it uses these to determine whether the camera or the microphone is being used on the device. Once you have given the permission, it will show green and orange indicators on the screen whenever the camera or the microphone are being used.
You can test this by opening the camera app on the device; a green dot should be displayed for as long as the camera app is active. The application does not need to be started to display the indicators; as soon as it is installed, it starts to display the indicators.
Access Dots includes some settings that you access from the preferences page. Only some of the settings are available to all users, others become available only after you may a donation to the author.
The settings that all users have access to allow you to change the color of each dot and the position on the screen. Options to change the position to a custom one and to change the size of the dots are reserved for users who donated to the developer.
Access Dots keeps track of camera and microphone activity, and you can access the data in the access log. There you find a chronological list of all activity that the application detected on the device. For each, date and time, the name of the app, and the length of access, are displayed in the table.
The application displays advertisement in its interface, e.g. the access log or configuration.
Safe Dot is an alternative that provides similar functionality.
Closing Words
While it is best to only install and run apps on the device that don't use the camera or microphone covertly, or at all, it may be helpful to run an app like Access Dots for some time to find out if any of the installed applications misbehave in this regard. Keep the application active for a day or two to find out if any applications use the camera or microphone without you knowing about it, and then remove it again.
You could reset application permissions if that is possible on the device as well to block apps from using the camera or microphone in first place.
Now You: How useful are the two indicators, what is your take on this?
I’m trying to get open source
The better and open-source version of this app.
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.aravi.dot
Source
https://github.com/kamaravichow/safe-dot-android
Anyone know a means to find out what app is using the permissions?
I pretty much have 4 non-stock apps, but my camera keeps activating. Android 10 on Samsung Note 9.
there are other dots – purple for example
unlike those, privacy indicators is free, open source and without ads
I have had the opportunity to better test the Privacy Indicators 1.2.1 Android app. My testing was done on Android 9 and Android 10.
The microphone and camera indicators do appear to display when many apps use them, such as a AOSP camera app or a voice notes recording app. However, when I tried to use the AOSP Phone app and placed a voice call, the Privacy Indicators app microphone indicator failed to display.
Safe Dot Pro is now available that supposedly should be safer to use and does not have INTERNET permission. I have not yet tried the software.
The Safe Dot Pro is advertised on Google Play at: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.aravi.dotpro
Privacy Indicators has now a Stable released and is supposed to be available for download on GitHub ( https://github.com/NitishGadangi/Privacy-Indicator-App/releases ), F-Droid (IzzyOnDroid repository), and Google Play ( https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.nitish.privacyindicator ). The Google Play distribution page does not yet advertise the software at the time of this writing.
Thanks so much for the tip!
Other than ads/trackers, Access Dots also have the problem of being a split-APK app. Privacy Indicators or Safe Dot do not have the issue.
For a description of of what split-APKs (also known as App Bundles) are and their problems, see:
https://raccoon.onyxbits.de/blog/merge-split-apk/
Thank you!
Very nice. Do remember with these kind of applications to disable for them any sort of battery optimisations, so they don’t get closed by the OS.
Do you have a link?
https://fossunited.org/project?project=Privacy%20Indicator%20App
I guess this one: https://github.com/NitishGadangi/Privacy-Indicator-App
Thank You!