A look at Open Shell (Classic Shell fork) - gHacks Tech News

ADVERTISEMENT

A look at Open Shell (Classic Shell fork)

Open Shell is a fork of the popular discontinued Classic Shell program for Windows that may restore a classic Start Menu, Explorer and Internet Explorer shell on the system.

Classic Shell was a popular program for Windows that restored functionality in Windows versions that Microsoft discontinued. The program rose in popularity after the initial release of Windows 8 as users preferred to work with a regular Start Menu and not the Start interface that Microsoft tried to push down everyone's throat.

Classic Shell was not the only program that saw a surge in user numbers as Start Menu programs were downloaded in record numbers.

The lead developer of Classic Shell announced in 2017 that he would quit development. He decided to publish the source code of the program to give other developers the chance to fork the program and continue development.

One of the first forks was called Classic Start. The first version of Classic Start was released in June 2018 and a first development released followed in the same month. The program was renamed to Open Shell in September 2018 when a first stable version was released.

open shell

The project is not dead as work on Nightly versions continues. Users may download and install these Nightly versions which are linked on the main GitHub page; it is not recommended to install these on production machines because though.

I downloaded the latest release version of Open Shell, version 4.4.131, and installed it on a system running the latest Windows 10 20H1 Insider build. Installation went through without issues. The classic Start Menu was restored after installation and most features worked just fine during the test.

I was able to change the Start Menu layout and make modifications to it. Some features did not work properly in that version, however. I was not able to change the taskbar design nor disable breadcrumbs in File Explorer.

One reason that the original developer of the program gave for quitting the project after all those years was that the Windows 10 update interval was too high. Granted, running Classic Shell on an Insider version of Windows 10 that won't be out for another six or so months is not entirely fair.

I decided to run it on a recent Windows 10 version 1903 build to find out whether it would have less bugs. The issues that I experienced on the Windows 10 20H1 machine were experienced on the Windows 10 version 1903 PC as well.

Considering that the latest stable version of Open Shell was released before Microsoft released Windows 10 version 1903, it did not come as a surprise that the issues were experienced in that version as well.

I downloaded the Nightly version of Open Shell to find out if the issues were resolved in that version; this was not the case unfortunately.

Closing Words

Open Shell suffers from Microsoft's fast paced development and the changes that the company makes to new versions of Windows 10. If you run earlier versions of Windows, you won't notice these issues or bugs.

Users who run Windows 10 can still use Open Shell to restore a classic Start Menu and use most of the functionality that it provides. Bugs should be expected, however.

Now You: do you use Classic Shell / Open Shell or another program to restore classic functionality?

Summary
software image
Author Rating
1star1star1star1stargray
5 based on 10 votes
Software Name
Open Shell
Operating System
Windows
Software Category
Productivity
Landing Page
Advertisement

Previous Post: «
Next Post: »

Comments

  1. RossN said on September 5, 2019 at 9:55 am
    Reply

    Yes, using Open Shell here. Windows 19 1903. I guess I haven’t done much customising so haven’t seen any bugs (yet).

  2. owl said on September 5, 2019 at 10:25 am
    Reply

    I am using it from Version 4.4.109 (2018/07/05).
    I use it as a “launcher function”, but I have no experience with bugs.
    Operating System: Windows 10 Home (x64) Version 1903 (build 18362.295)

    Open Shell is a favorite tool that replaces the default “Start menu”.

  3. Rocky said on September 5, 2019 at 10:32 am
    Reply

    At first I dislike the Win10 start menu. However when I customised the tiles to reflect my most commonly used programs I changed my mind and now quite like how quickly I can access programs without also having the desktop or task bar full of shortcuts .

    1. joker538538 said on September 5, 2019 at 7:30 pm
      Reply

      But still very bad, the density looks like mobile at least for me, and it lags a lot, even on ssd.

    2. DaveyK said on September 5, 2019 at 9:36 pm
      Reply

      This is true, however I always preferred making the Windows 7 Start Menu taller and then pinning my most used apps to the left hand side. I do the same with OpenShell on my Windows 10 laptop and find it far more user friendly to have a list with names than the grid of pinned icons only on my work laptop (can’t put OpenShell on that unfortunately). I also hate that the Windows 10 Start Menu ignores the Windows accessibility options such as smooth scrolling as well…

  4. Avi said on September 5, 2019 at 10:34 am
    Reply

    Still on Classic Shell. I use only Classic Menu and it works perfectly on 1903.

    1. GregoryV said on September 5, 2019 at 12:13 pm
      Reply

      same here

    2. Belga said on September 5, 2019 at 1:02 pm
      Reply

      Same Here on Win 7 & 8.1 !

    3. John Fenderson said on September 5, 2019 at 4:46 pm
      Reply

      @Avi:

      Me as well!

  5. Andy said on September 5, 2019 at 10:57 am
    Reply

    I use it as well. No issues knock on wood.

  6. Pedro said on September 5, 2019 at 11:04 am
    Reply

    I also use Open Shell, but mainly to change the Start Button appearance since I actually prefer the Windows 10 Start Menu (I just use it as an app launcher since I right click the Windows Explorer icon to access preferred locations, and each of the programs on the taskbar for pinned and recent documents).

  7. Peter said on September 5, 2019 at 11:09 am
    Reply
    1. Alex said on September 5, 2019 at 12:20 pm
      Reply

      That’s a nightly version – not the stable as found on GitHub. So, not recommended for standard users.

      No bugs/issues here, only using the Start Menu module.

  8. Gavin B. said on September 5, 2019 at 11:45 am
    Reply

    I’m still loving Classic Shell on Windows 10 1809

  9. chesscanoe said on September 5, 2019 at 1:32 pm
    Reply

    Maybe a month after Classic Shell was understandably abandoned, I gave up on trying to tolerate its successors, and maximized what I could do with Windows 10 natively. Currently I run Microsoft Windows [Version 10.0.18362.329] and am pleased I am not chasing Classic Shell successors so far unsuccessful efforts to make their offerings bug free for my way of working.

  10. Claudio said on September 5, 2019 at 1:47 pm
    Reply

    Buongiorno , io uso da anni Start Menù X ( ex Vista Start Menù) … validissimo per me…

  11. rip said on September 5, 2019 at 1:54 pm
    Reply

    Combined with 7+ Taskbar Tweaker (Ram Michael) I’m happy as can be.

    Every time I see the hideous tiles of that “metro” scheme I want to throw up. Screen real-estate is too valuable to pollute with those huge push-buttons (and my screen is not touch enabled.)

    1. owl said on September 6, 2019 at 2:03 am
      Reply

      About “7+ Taskbar Tweaker”,
      7+ Taskbar Tweaker – RaMMicHaeL’s Blog | https://rammichael.com/
      https://rammichael.com/7-taskbar-tweaker

      “7+ Taskbar Tweaker” has previous experience.
      It’s a lot of settings, but there is nothing special in Windows 10 (since Windows 10 offers similar function settings and can be set in too other apps).
      What is for you, a unique point of this app?

  12. Mele said on September 5, 2019 at 1:54 pm
    Reply

    I use Stardock’s Start10 and WindowBlinds 10 on Windows 10 Pro version 1803 and Start8 and WindowBlinds 8 on my Windows 8.0 Pro computer. They are great. I tried Classic Shell on my Windows 8.0 Pro computer but liked Start8 better plus WindowBlinds was essential on Windows 8 due to the gray font (rather than black that Microsoft promised to fix but never did). Since the two are from the same company they work well together. They are well worth the modest amount of money I paid for them.

    I keep checking the box to save my name, email, etc in this browser but nothing gets saved. ?

  13. ULBoom said on September 5, 2019 at 2:16 pm
    Reply

    Still using Classic Start Menu (part of Classic Shell) v. 4.3.1, Aug 2017 and it works fine, no bugs, on Win 10 v.1903.

  14. Jeff said on September 5, 2019 at 2:37 pm
    Reply

    The original Classic Shell works on Windows 10 1903 and everything works so I am not sure why people install Open Shell.

    1. The person who maintains Open Shell broke it for multiple monitors support. There’s a thread on Tenforums about it.
    2. Taskbar modifications in original Classic Shell works on Windows 10 1903 (which is reported in the article to not work with Open Shell). In the following pic I have forced enabled glass. Taskbar textures also work.
    3. Breadcrumbs can also be disabled in the original Classic Shell (again reported to be broken): https://imgur.com/QJvo0FW

    I think you did not set it up properly. Explorer functionality requires its extensions (Browser Helper Objects) to be enabled in IE because Microsoft built a shared add-on architecture for IE and Explorer back in those days.

    Just for note: Classic Shell is a Win32 app using Win32 APIs, a FULL re-implementation not a hack using Windows files. It does not patch or modify Windows system files either. The Start menu process injects in memory into Explorer to hook the Win key with the keyboard. As soon as you exit it, it reverts Windows to its original functionality.

    The Explorer add-ons are proper shell extensions. The modifications are done in-memory (not by patching files) just like the other Explorer mod: OldNewExplorer.

  15. Jeff said on September 5, 2019 at 2:40 pm
    Reply

    Also forgot to mention that some Explorer tweaks require you to log off and login again, some require restarting Explorer. All this after the addons are properly enabled using inetcpl.cpl (IE’s Internet Options). This may be the reason many declare it as “Not working any more” or “broken now” without properly setting it up.

  16. Bill Gates said on September 5, 2019 at 3:02 pm
    Reply

    I’m looking for a way to remove the start menu on Windows 10. I haven’t used it for almost a decade.
    I only use portable apps, besides, when you click start menu windows runs stuff on background.
    Can this program vanish start menu?

  17. Gabriel said on September 5, 2019 at 5:31 pm
    Reply

    Startisback++ is only $4 USD. Works perfectly as far as I know.
    It’s updated frequently.

    1. Harry Ballz said on September 5, 2019 at 7:09 pm
      Reply

      I concur. Startisback++ is my preferred solution to the Windows 10 Start Menu problem. Well-designed, works great, and worth the few dollars.

    2. Martin Brinkmann said on September 5, 2019 at 7:34 pm
      Reply

      Since it was mentioned several times, here is our review of version 2.0: https://www.ghacks.net/2017/03/27/windows-10-start-menu-startisback-2-0-released/

  18. pHROZEN gHOST said on September 5, 2019 at 8:43 pm
    Reply

    I have been using the original and then the fork since Win 10 came out. I turned off the explorer component. I use QTabbar to give explorer tabs.

    I have no issues with the latest stable version. It’s way better than the Win 10 start menu.

    1. owl said on September 6, 2019 at 1:02 am
      Reply

      About QTTabbar,
      “QTTabBar” was my previous favorite.
      However, in Windows 10, every time it was updated (1704> 1709> 1803), “Tab display” Modulate (Tab disappears etc.), so I gave up using it.
      Does it work properly in 1903?
      Operating System: Windows 10 (x64) Version 1903 (build 18362.295)

    2. owl said on September 6, 2019 at 12:51 pm
      Reply

      About QTTabBar,
      QTTabBar – QuizoApps | http://qttabbar.wikidot.com/
      Change Log – QuizoApps | http://qttabbar.wikidot.com/change-log
      I decided to try “ver 1040 (2019-3-24) New”.
      @pHROZEN gHOST, Thanks for mentioning.
      Thank you.

  19. YetAnotherPowerUser said on September 5, 2019 at 10:02 pm
    Reply

    When Classic Shell ended, I tried other free alternatives with some success, but they still lacked.

    Then I learned we can simply do this:

    1) Make a folder and call it My Software
    2) In that folder, make folders of all your software types, such as “security”, “media players”, “media tools”, and “games”.
    3) Put shortcuts to your software in those folders.
    4) Add that “My Software” folder to your Windows taskbar as a Toolbar.
    5) Simply access all your software from that Toolbar.

    I find this the best method, as I can organize my software the way I want. We can even have 2 or more shortcuts of the same software in different folders, such as having foobar in “media players” and in “media tools”.

    This level of organizing can not be automated.

    Also, if you have Geek Uninstaller, when you remove a program with that, it will also remove all the shortcuts to it. Thus you don’t have to fuss with managing your My Software folders when you remove a program.

    As for “Apps”, such as from Microsoft Store, I guess making shortcuts for those is not so easy, so this method may not work with those? I don’t know, as I don’t use “Apps”, as I think they suck.

    As for being able to see the most recently used and installed software, I could care less about those features.

    That all said, I never left click my Start button anymore, as I have no need for a “Start Menu”.

    1. mikef90000 said on September 8, 2019 at 1:33 am
      Reply

      Thank you for documenting this capability which is similar to what I used on WinXP long ago. Presumably shortcuts for documents can be put into their own folders to organize them as ‘projects’ or some such.

      IIRC the newer versions of Windows have a similar organizing capability but it seemed so convoluted I never figure it out completely – will have to revisit Win7 for a refresher.

    2. mikef90000 said on September 8, 2019 at 1:40 am
      Reply

      Meant to add that I use the Xfce desktop on Linux most of the time and the ‘start’ menu is just there for a default app launcher; you can put your own ‘favorites’ directly on panels on any edge of the screen. The ‘directory menu’ widget is the exact analogue of the above Windows technique.

      1. YetAnotherPowerUser said on September 9, 2019 at 3:46 am
        Reply

        @mikef90000

        Thanks for your tips about Xfce. I do tend to like Xfce the most, as I keep coming back to it when I use Linux.

        Furthermore to my previous comment about Windows 10, I sometimes still right-click my Start button to access those other Windows features. Yet for the most part, I have made “System” shortcuts and such of my own, and likewise made a Toolbar for those. Also, some functions such as “Shut down” I now have available in my right-click Context Menu, thanks to tools like Easy Context Menu, Ultimate Windows Tweaker, and Winaero Tweaker.

        I find it sad I have to use such OS tweakers, but alas, after Windows XP they started fluffing their OS with more and more superfluous eye candy, that all too many users are acquiescent in gagging on.

        Yet I have little to complain about Windows 10, yet I love to complain about what little I can.

  20. Mothy said on September 6, 2019 at 3:09 am
    Reply

    Been using Classic Shell (Start Menu only) since Win 8.1 Pro in 2014 through Win 10 Pro 1903 and no issues with it. So never worried about or looked for software updates for it. If it ain’t broke…

  21. Stan said on September 6, 2019 at 5:49 am
    Reply

    I think I must have started using Classic Shell with Windows 8, and it came along when I upgraded to W10. I didn’t even know it was abandoned until well after I got the error messages and found Open-Shell at classicshell.net. I get the feeling that all they did was they made it work without the error messages and changed everywhere it said Classic-Shell to Open-Shell.

    My other go-to program for W10 is Clover. It provides a chrome-like tabbed interface, but the best part is that you can pin(?) shortcuts just above the ribbon.

    Contrary to what others have said or experienced, neither Classic or Open-Shell have caused me any problems with multiple monitors or anything else on any of the several machines I’ve installed it on.

  22. Mountainking said on September 6, 2019 at 6:18 am
    Reply

    @martin: “Open Shell suffers from Microsoft’s fast paced development and the changes that the company makes to new versions of Windows 10. If you run earlier versions of Windows, you won’t notice these issues or bugs.

    Users who run Windows 10 can still use Open Shell to restore a classic Start Menu and use most of the functionality that it provides. Bugs should be expected, however.”

    This is a ludicrous claim. I’ve been using open shell as a replacement of classic shell (after trying paid softwares and not liking it) and it’s been bug free. If you have encountered any bugs or any bugs, post it. BUT saying that fast paced windows 10 development is just causing bugs to appear and impacting users, you should at least back it up at the break of functionality….

  23. Pierre said on September 6, 2019 at 7:29 am
    Reply

    Thanks to the author !
    That kind of program is mainly interesting for Windows 8.1
    For Windows 10 I prefer the native start menu

  24. Darren said on September 6, 2019 at 8:32 am
    Reply

    Startisback++

    The cure for Microsoft’s poor excuse for a start menu / launcher.

  25. Antonio said on September 6, 2019 at 8:34 am
    Reply

    Does anybody know a shell replacement that puts start button & menu on the right (or in the middle) of the screen?

  26. Jozsef said on September 6, 2019 at 9:41 am
    Reply

    I finally switched from XP to Windows 8 and discovered Classic Shell then. I began using it on every Windows computer after that, primarily to change the horrible keyhole style program list to the flyout style of XP on Vista and 7 systems. All my customers and friends prefer this change. Nowadays on 10, I always install Open Shell in the belief that it will be kept up to date.

    Windows 10 convinced me to finally try Win 7 out of nostalgia for a sane UI and if I don’t manage a move to Linux by January, I can just return to 8 so either way, Windows 10 issues will never affect me personally.

    I must say that changes made to the configuration dialogs in Open Shell have made it more difficult and confusing to select options as I see it but it’s not a deal breaker.

  27. syrup said on September 7, 2019 at 7:37 am
    Reply

    Been using Classic Shell (the final version, 4.3.1) since setting up my Windows 8.1 rig a couple of years ago. Don’t have a bad thing to say about it – has done the job well and been refreshingly set-and-forget. Probably helps that 8.1 doesn’t “suffer from Microsoft’s fast paced development and the changes that the company makes to new versions of Windows 10”.

  28. BlackSuri said on September 7, 2019 at 5:42 pm
    Reply

    I use Classic Shell (Start Menu only) on 4 computers, and am very pleased with it. However, I recently purchased a Lenovo Yoga C630 with a Snapdragon ARM processor, running Windows 10 Pro, and Classic Shell won’t run. OpenShell runs, but nothing happens.

    Despite extensive Google searches, I can’t find anything that will give me the look of the Windows 7 Start Menu on an ARM processor. Does anyone know of any program that will?

Leave a Reply

Check the box to consent to your data being stored in line with the guidelines set out in our privacy policy

Please note that your comment may not appear immediately after you post it.