YouTube is testing large thumbnails on the homepage - gHacks Tech News

YouTube is testing large thumbnails on the homepage

If you have been to the streaming video site YouTube lately you may have noticed that the design of the homepage changed.

Google is apparently at it again with yet another test that changes the layout of the homepage of YouTube. The company uses A-B tests to analyze changes and help with the decision making process; the data helps Google decide whether a change should be implemented or not.

This particular change is visible to a fraction of the user base only at the time of writing. The YouTube homepage displays larger thumbnails when you open it; the current homepage displays small thumbnails next to each other. The video suggestions are sorted into groups such as recommended, from your subscriptions, or specific channels that you watched in the past or that others watched.

The new design does away with the grouping of content. Instead, all you get is a never ending stream of video listings supported by large thumbnails.

youtube-new design large thumbnails

The new large thumbnail design is active on the YouTube homepage only. When you search, or browse subscriptions or trending listings, you will get the standard layouts.

The new design puts video thumbnails front and center. You might want to install the YouTube Clickbait Remover extension to prevent misuse of custom thumbnails on the site.

One effect of larger thumbnails is that you see fewer videos at a time. On my system, YouTube showed just six videos, two of them only half, on a page. The old design showed nine videos on a page without scrolling.

Closing Words

Large video thumbnails may look nicer and they may work better on TV screens even. The experience may be different on the desktop. YouTube displays fewer videos on a page which results in more scrolling. The removal of groups makes the whole homepage look even more random than before as you get even fewer control over what is displayed.

You could hide certain channels recommended to you in the old design, the new does not display any groups or channels so that the option is not there anymore.

Don't like videos from a particular channel recommended to you over and over again? The only option left is to use third-party tools to block content on YouTube.

The change feels more like another attempt to remove choice from YouTube, not that there has been much to begin with, and spoon feed videos that YouTube's algorithm selects to users. Yes, there is search and subscriptions that give you some control, but the clear simplification trend continues unhindered.

It is possible that the new design will be discarded again.

Now You: what is your take on the new design?

Summary
YouTube is testing large thumbnails on the homepage
Article Name
YouTube is testing large thumbnails on the homepage
Description
If you have been to the streaming video site YouTube lately you may have noticed that the design of the homepage changed.
Author
Publisher
Ghacks Technology News
Logo
Advertisement

We need your help

Advertising revenue is falling fast across the Internet, and independently-run sites like Ghacks are hit hardest by it. The advertising model in its current form is coming to an end, and we have to find other ways to continue operating this site.

We are committed to keeping our content free and independent, which means no paywalls, no sponsored posts, no annoying ad formats or subscription fees.

If you like our content, and would like to help, please consider making a contribution:


Previous Post: «
Next Post:

Comments

  1. Aegis said on August 14, 2019 at 8:58 am
    Reply

    I won’t notice such changes since I use a userscript to force use the old design in Firefox. Also I always use a bookmark to go direct to the subscription page. I almost never go to the home page of youtube.

    1. sonar said on August 14, 2019 at 11:49 am
      Reply

      Even better. Use dedicated RSS reader to follow your favorite channels. No reason to ever visit the broken YouTube webpage.

      1. vip said on August 14, 2019 at 4:17 pm
        Reply

        How will you ever discover anything new if you go to the same ol’ places over and over and over again?

  2. Paulus said on August 14, 2019 at 9:33 am
    Reply

    Yes, it certainly feels and also looks like a attempt to give Google paying advertisement customers a possibility to push there product under main nose.

    So it feels a lot like the Thumbnail (books) burning because all this knowledge is not good for the much to sensitive not most of all not paying souls.
    It really starting to feel like the YouTube variant of the question of whether the Chinese Taoist philosopher Lao Zi really existed.

  3. ShintoPlasm said on August 14, 2019 at 10:25 am
    Reply

    The mobilification continues full steam ahead. God, I hate these changes! Everything has to be big, massive, huuuuuge – even with massive screens at high resolutions, you UI will still resemble a child’s toy for enormous, clumsy fingers. Gah!

  4. ilev said on August 14, 2019 at 11:15 am
    Reply

    I use a Chrome extension : Magic Actions for YouTube. No ads, no recommendations, no thumbnails, no tabs… pure full screen YouTube streaming.

  5. Susan said on August 14, 2019 at 12:35 pm
    Reply

    Excellent! CNN’s Fredo Cuomo looks very handsome in a large thumbnail.

  6. Shawn said on August 14, 2019 at 12:58 pm
    Reply

    What’s funny is that these dumb dumb’s created this for TV use and almost never publicize it.

    https://www.youtube.com/tv#/surface?c=FEtopics&resume

  7. Tom Hawack said on August 14, 2019 at 5:51 pm
    Reply

    All embedded YouTube videos here are redirected to Invidious instance, the same instance I use for viewing YouTube videos. I avoid YouTube since I’ve discovered Invidious, true even if the wording sounds like an advertisement.

    Invidious instances display larger video thumbnails than YouTube but maybe not as wide as announced YouTube display. On a personal note I prefer smaller thumbnails hence more on a given screen area, but “small” is subjective and also depends of the user’s screen dimensions.

  8. amir said on August 14, 2019 at 10:15 pm
    Reply
  9. Bob said on August 14, 2019 at 10:19 pm
    Reply

    I’ve had that new homepage for a few weeks now. I get pretty much the same selection as I did before, but can’t fit nearly as many thumbnails on screen at one time.

    Hiding various groups like Recommended or YT Originals never had a permanent effect so were a bit pointless.

  10. Yuliya said on August 14, 2019 at 11:25 pm
    Reply

    I bought a 27in monitor so I can view four video thumbnails at once on YouTube. Yaaay!!
    Horrible!! But then again so is the rest of the current YT site design, even the video controls popup takes like half the screen’s height.

  11. Richard Steven Hack said on August 14, 2019 at 11:48 pm
    Reply

    “Don’t like videos from a particular channel recommended to you over and over again?”

    This is my number one problem with Youtube. I don’t visit the Youtube Home Page, I just open up Youtube while signed in with Gmail and it shows me a bunch of video thumbnails. If they change that to larger thumbnails, I will be very upset (again).

    The main problem is Youtube showing me options from ten years ago, and endlessly stuff I’ve already watched or have zero interest in. I’ve taken to clicking on everything on the page “Not Interested”, then the “Tell Us Why” stating that I’ve seen the video or I’m not interested in the channel. This takes up a lot of time.

    The other point is I will refresh the page numerous times to see if I can get offered something new (that isn’t ten years old.) Eventually the page simply shows most of the same things each time it is refreshed – a sign that I might as well stop.

    My video interests are very specific: exercise, firearms, computer security, and martial arts. Anything else I might be interested in I will use the Search to find. Showing me anything else is a waste of my time. If their algorithms were intended to reflect my interests, it would show me those topics. But of course their algorithm is to support their advertisers.

    I use youtube-dl (with a GUI) to download Youtube videos I’m interested in. This is one way I avoid being shown a bunch of stuff I’m not interested in if I view something online which is a momentary interest.

    All that said, I do view Youtube as a valuable resource. I’ve downloaded gigabytes of instructional videos that are very valuable. I just wish they would make more effort to show me stuff I’m interested in when offering me videos.

  12. ULBoom said on August 15, 2019 at 12:36 am
    Reply

    I get 15 videos per page, not surprised YouTube is different for everyone. Content’s still great, a guy with impossibly large muscles fishing, cat with eyes the size of billiard balls…

    I like the big blurry thumbnails shown here; reminds me of fuzz butts/boobs on that ridiculous TV show Naked and Afraid. They apparently have an XL version now, too. Bigger fuzz, I guess.

    YouTube can do what they want, won’t make anyone but obliviots click on the stupid stuff purposely. Meanwhile, they buried my channel controls in garbage “features” I couldn’t care less about. They treat their contributors and drive by clickers the same, like dirt.

  13. John Fenderson said on August 16, 2019 at 12:24 am
    Reply

    Because I don’t trust Google, I use YouTube only on a tablet dedicated to that use alone, and use the app rather than the website, so I don’t see these changes.

    That said, I tend to be generally allergic to large thumbnails like that. They’re a space-waster. If I used the website, I’d very probably dislike the change.

  14. Cybershaman said on August 17, 2019 at 3:19 pm
    Reply

    UGH!!! The new “format” is just gawd-awful. Yeah, it does have slightly bigger thumbnails, but who was asking for that??? And now they are just randomly skewed all over the screen with no semblance of order whatsoever. You know what? It reminds me of Google+. Remember Google+? And how “easy” it was to find posts/comments? Yeah, that right. It, too, had everything just pasted on the screen without a care or even an allusion to order. It’s like they just gave up. Does somebody there REALLY think that it’s an improvement??? You know, I used to think that Google had some of the best minds working there. But this just smacks of someone trying to justify their reason for being employed. It’s a pointless, middle management exercise in frivolity. In fact, whoever did this should be immediately shown the door. It’s downright shameful.

Leave a Reply

Check the box to consent to your data being stored in line with the guidelines set out in our privacy policy

Please note that your comment may not appear immediately after you post it.