Sony Wins $2.6 Billion UK Lawsuit Over PlayStation Store Prices

Sony has won the UK class action over PlayStation Store prices. London's Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed the claim in its entirety on Tuesday, ruling that the claimants failed to prove that Sony broke competition law. The final claim was for £1.49 billion in damages, or £1.97 billion, about $2.6 billion, with interest.
Consumer rights campaigner Alex Neill filed the case in August 2022 on behalf of about nine million UK PlayStation users. At the time, it was worth up to £5 billion. By the trial in March, it covered around 12.2 million players.
What the PlayStation Store Lawsuit Claimed
Neill argued that Sony abused its control of the PlayStation Store. Retailers compete on the price of boxed games, but Sony alone sets the price of digital games and add ons on its console. The case claimed that:
- Sony's 30 percent cut on digital sales pushed up prices
- players would have paid around 20 percent less if rival stores were allowed on PlayStation
- buying a PlayStation locked players into Sony's digital prices
The tribunal rejected these arguments. It found that people choosing between a PlayStation, an Xbox and a Nintendo console can take the price of games into account before they buy. For console owners with a disc drive, cheaper boxed copies also gave Sony a reason to keep digital prices competitive.
The tribunal also looked at how Sony makes money from PlayStation. Sony sells consoles at thin margins or at a loss and earns that money back from game sales. Looking at the business as a whole, the tribunal found no evidence that Sony's profits were excessive.
Can Neill Appeal the Ruling?
The case may not be over. Neill says she is considering an appeal, and the tribunal will hear any application for permission to appeal during the week of December 14.
The ruling also points to a risk for players. Sony will stop releasing new PlayStation games on disc in January 2028, although publishers can still reorder discs for existing games. The tribunal said this change falls outside the period the lawsuit covered, but noted that losing competition from boxed copies could give Sony room to raise digital prices.
The gap between disc and digital prices is already visible. A price comparison of 16 PS5 games in the Netherlands in July found that Final Fantasy VII Rebirth was cheaper on disc than on the Dutch PlayStation Store around 90 percent of the time. Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart still cost €80 on the PlayStation Store five years after launch, while a new boxed copy sold for around €40.
Leave a Reply