Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over a Facebook Feature That Scanned Android Camera Rolls

Arthur Kay
Updated •
Big Tech, Meta

Italy's data protection authority, the Garante Privacy, has fined Meta €805 million, about $887 million, over a Facebook feature that accessed the photos and videos of Android users without proper permission. It is the largest penalty the Italian regulator has ever issued.

The fine targets a Facebook feature called "Get camera roll suggestions when you're browsing Facebook." Available since 2023, it suggests photos and videos from the Android camera roll as ideas for new posts.

Why Italy Fined Meta

The regulator opened its investigation in July 2025 after a report from the consumer protection organization Centro Tutela Consumatori Utenti of Bolzano, and ran its own technical analysis of the app. It concluded that the feature broke Italy's privacy code, which implements the European ePrivacy Directive, and Article 122 of the Italian Data Protection Code. The regulator found that:

  • Facebook asked for camera roll access with a single, app wide permission
  • the permission came after a vague notice to "enable other features" that did not mention camera roll suggestions
  • the feature was turned on by default
  • around 20 million Italian Android users were affected

When granted in full, this kind of permission lets the app read the entire photo library on the device, usually permanently, without the user or the regulator being able to check what is actually used.

The Garante says Article 122 protects the smartphone as part of a person's private sphere, so any access to its contents needs free and informed consent, whether or not data is transmitted or harm occurs. Users who have not updated the Facebook app, or who already granted the permission, are still affected.

Meta argued that the Irish data protection authority should handle the case. The Garante rejected this, because the ePrivacy rules have no one stop shop mechanism. The case did not cover whether the photos were used to train AI, which Meta denies, and the Garante says it will examine a newer feature from 2026 that processes camera roll content in the cloud separately.

The Garante says Meta did not fully cooperate during the investigation, and that this contributed to the size of the fine, along with the number of users affected and a previous 2019 decision against the company.

Changes Meta made after the report counted in its favor, but the regulator called them late and limited to users who update the app. The penalty equals roughly 0.47 percent of Meta's global turnover.

What Meta Has to Change

If Meta does not comply in time, the feature cannot be turned on for users who have not given valid consent. The order requires Meta to:

  1. make these changes within 60 days
  2. ask for a separate, specific consent for the feature and explain what it does and how to turn it off
  3. keep the feature off by default, even for users who already granted the permission
  4. report the steps it has started within 30 days and the measures it has taken within 90 days

Meta says it will appeal. A company spokesperson called the fine disproportionate and said the feature simply helps people post new content to their Facebook feeds. According to Meta, permission is always required and users can change it at any time in the app's settings.

The fine adds to legal pressure on Meta over how it handles user data. In October, a New Mexico judge ordered Meta to pay $25 billion after a jury found it had violated the state's consumer protection laws more than 43 million times.

Meta has not said whether it will change the camera roll feature in other countries.

Comments

There are no comments on this post yet, be the first one to share your thoughts!

Leave a Reply

By commenting, you accept our privacy policy and keep the discussion respectful and on topic.