Amazon's Echo Show devices are displaying full-screen ads

Ashwin Karthik
Updated •
Amazon

Amazon launched some Alexa-enabled Echo devices a week ago. The result has been absolutely chaotic, full-screen ads on smart displays.

Update: We updated the article to reflect two inaccuracies. First, some of the new Echo devices are not yet available. Second, that every ad on Amazon uses a label that clearly identifies it as promoted or sponsored. We also added a statement from Amazon.

Ads aren't new in Amazon's devices, ad-supported Kindle eReaders have been sold for a long time, they cost a little less than the regular versions. You may be aware that Prime Video has ads too. And ads on Alexa devices are not new either, they have been around for a couple of years. Up until now, the ad experience has been relatively muted, even on the Echo Show.

That changed with the release of new models, which appears to be rather spammy with ads. Some of the announced devices, like the Echo Dot Max or Echo Studio, are only available for preorder at the time of writing. It is unclear if they may show similar behavior.

According to The Verge's Jennifer Pattison Tuohy, the ads seem to be appearing on the smart home devices frequently, very frequently. On an Echo Show 8, an ad appeared once between two photos, and this happened many times. And you can't turn them off, or opt out of it.

The ads are full-screen and labeled as sponsored or promoted. Amazon's Echo Show just "highlights" the products that you may be interested in. It's an unpleasant experience, but one we should have seen coming, especially in this day and age, where ad-supported is basically the starter tier. It is no a longer consumer-first economy.

Amazon provided us with the following statement: "Echo Show devices are designed to be customized and surface relevant content for customers—such as music and TV shows they may like, weather, sports updates, and local news. Advertising is a small part of the experience, and it helps customers discover new content and products they may be interested in. If customers don’t like a suggestion, they can swipe to skip to the next screen card, or directly provide feedback by tapping the Information icon or pressing the screen.” 

Earlier this year, Amazon introduced Alexa Plus, its AI-powered assistant, which shouldn't come as a surprise. A couple of months ago, Amazon announced an Alexa+ Home screen Ad program, which displays full-screen ads for products on Alexa+ powered Echo Show Devices. This was launched in the US, UK and Germany. This was a part of Amazon's marketing strategies, to improve its revenue from its Devices & Services division.

The Division's head, Panos Panay, had told Tuohy, that the ads are not ads, if they are relevant. He called them "an add-on", which can help customers who are looking for something specific. But he also admitted that the current state of the ads were randomized. That would explain why users have been getting ads for products that they were not interested in. What next? Ads on the speaker? Speaking of which, remember when Amazon disabled local processing of Alexa voice requests. Coincidence?

Users can swipe to the next screen, or press the information button to provide feedback. But none of these stop the ads. Echo users on Reddit are annoyed by the changes, with some saying that they have unplugged their Echo Show due to the intrusive ads, others said they have cancelled their Amazon Prime subscription, and have switched to different speakers.

Do you have an Amazon Echo Show? Will you buy one knowing it will display ads?

Comments

  1. pinoybear said on
    Reply

    The Apple TV 4K was the first Apple device in my home because I couldn’t deal with the Fire TV UI cluttered with ads

  2. Anon said on
    Reply

    Ads should be banned from existence

  3. Allwynd said on
    Reply

    I don’t know what those devices are used for, probably not popular in my country. If I want to watch something, I don’t even download torrents anymore. I know a couple of websites, some for movies and TV series, some for anime and I watch there. They probably have and pop ups, but Brave blocks them so I don’t know. Luckily there are good browsers with solid content blocking on both PC and mobile so all my Linux PCs and laptops have Brave and my Android phone has Brave too.

  4. Amazoned said on
    Reply

    This is disgusting and should be banned on all “smart devices”. Imagine paying $220 for a gadget that spies on you and shows you adverts.

  5. Kevin said on
    Reply

    I presume users may pay a premium to suppress advertising if they wish, or does your Prime ad-free subscription cover it for you?

  6. carrymeplz said on
    Reply

    I will definitely avoid contraptions that just show me ads. I pay for a Brazilian Prime subscription that’s LESS THAN $4/month. The only show I watched was Fallout and I installed an ad blocker that removed their ads while I was in the US watching. If I had to pay full US-price for Prime, I wouldn’t.

  7. JuhaT said on
    Reply

    Nope, I never want to pay for something that shows ads. Just cancelled my Prime on Amazon. Not a big loss though, I have seen the few things that were worthy to watch here in Sweden so it wasnt worth to pay extra to be free from ads.

  8. Greg said on
    Reply

    While I understand the business side of having advertisements. The intrusive ads that take over on devices that you pay for should stop. If companies dont stop this, my hope is the consumers will wake up and stop buying thease devices, and stop supporting thease companies buy canceling subscriptions.

Leave a Reply

By commenting, you accept our privacy policy and keep the discussion respectful and on topic.