Australian court finds Apple, Google guilty of being anticompetitive

Ashwin Karthik
Apple, Google

Apple and Google have been dealt a big blow in a Federal Court trial in Australia. The App Store and Google Play Store were deemed to be anticompetitive.

Epic Games had sued Apple and Google in 2020, due to their app markets' 30% commission fees, and the removal of Fortnite from the two stores. The Sydney Morning Herald reports that the lawsuits began 5 years ago as four separate cases, but since some issues overlapped, they were heard as a single trial.

Epic may have lost its antitrust battle against Apple in the U.S., but it won its lawsuit against Google, which was found to have built an illegal monopoly in the Android market.

Its case in Australia was based on similar claims. Epic had claimed that the tech giants maintained an illegal monopoly over their app markets, and created walled gardens that locked out rival app stores, including its own. Apple and Google had argued that these claims were false, and that restrictions placed on their app stores were to protect the privacy and security of its users.

In a judgment that spanned 2000 pages, Australian Federal Court Justice Jonathan Beach, ruled that Apple had a substantial degree of market power. The Judge said both Apple and Google had breached Section 46 of Australia’s Competition Act. The companies had abused their market power to stifle the competition. But, it wasn't all in favor of Epic Games. Beach rejected the claim that Apple and Google had breached consumer law, he also said that the companies had not engaged in unconscionable conduct.

Apple said welcomed the court's rejection of some of Epic Games' claims, and that it disagreed with the rulings on others. Google also welcomed the rejection of some claims, but disagreed with the characterization of its billing policies, practices, and some partnerships. Google is reviewing the decision, to assess its next steps.

Epic Games has said that Fortnite will soon be available in Australia, along with the Epic Games Store for iOS. Fortnite had recently returned to iPhones in the U.S.

Comments

  1. boris said on
    Reply

    I would say, please find a huge corporation that is not anticompetitive. Please post if such corporation exists.

    1. Kevin said on
      Reply

      The problem is not whistling and pointing at a company you think is anticompetitive, the problem is proving it.

      1. Tom Hawack said on
        Reply

        That’s why in good old novels cops would hit you with a phone-book rather than with fists: leaves no marks hence no evidence.
        Gagarin’s first orbital flight: where is God, I don’t see Him? (though he must have thought ‘god’).
        The sixties and their good or bad ‘vibes’ mentioned everywhere at he time.
        So many realities which cannot or hardly be “proven”. Does not mean they exist, not that they don’t, only that they may.
        Of course that big corporations have no human limit, otherwise they wouldn’t be that powerful. A leftist, especially French, asserts that being successful means being dishonest, which is an absurdity. A moderate rightist will assert that being successful is not relevant of dishonesty (I know quite a few which do good business honestly), but that, having climbed to the highest levels of welfare and power is undoubtedly relevant of a total lack of respect and consideration for those who nourish their businesses. That’s how it is.

      2. boris said on
        Reply

        @Tom Hawack

        “A leftist, especially French, asserts that being successful means being dishonest, which is an absurdity.”

        I hear this from left channels all the time. Is it without a merit? I have to disagree with you. If Government officials and public institutions were perfect, it would be a nonsense. But they are not. I remember “Back to School” (1986) movie where an old businessman went back to college to have fun with his dorky freshman son. I remember his first class where the teacher (I think she was his love interest too) started to discuss everything somebody need to start a new business. Everything she said was above board. When she finished, he gave the class a lesson on how many people has to be bribed just to open the smallest business in the smallest town. I do not remember how many now, but it was at least few local Government officials and few Unions. Otherwise, nobody can open any business.

Leave a Reply

By commenting, you accept our privacy policy and keep the discussion respectful and on topic.