How to make Thunderbird open emails in a new or the same window
Thunderbird opens messages in a new tab by default. To open them in a separate window instead, open the Thunderbird settings, go to General, scroll to Reading & Display and change "Open messages in" to "A new message window" (one window per email) or "An existing message window" (one shared window).
The change takes effect immediately and you can switch back at any time. This guide also covers the close-on-move option and the config editor preference mail.openMessageBehavior for admins.

Some users prefer a single window because it stays tidy, but only one email can be shown at a time then. If you want several messages side by side, use multiple windows. The older guide on turning off tabs in Thunderbird covers the same idea for earlier versions.
Thunderbird: open emails in windows
Thunderbird opens email in a new window when "Open messages in" is set to a window option. Here is how to configure it:
- Open Thunderbird.
- Open the preferences: Tools > Preferences (labeled Settings in newer versions). If the menu bar is hidden, tap the Alt key to show it temporarily.
- On the General tab, scroll down to the Reading & Display section.
There you find "Open messages in". The options are:
- A new tab: the default; each email loads in its own tab, and tabs are restored the next time Thunderbird starts if it was not closed first.
- A new message window: each email opens in its own window, so multiple windows can be open at once.
- An existing message window: one window is reused; selecting another email replaces the one shown.
A related checkbox, "close message window/tab on move or delete", closes the tab or window automatically when the loaded email is moved or deleted. Option names and menu paths vary a little between Thunderbird versions, so look for the same wording on your build.
Advanced Information
Admins can set the behavior in the Config Editor or in configuration files. The preference is mail.openMessageBehavior.

- Open the Thunderbird preferences and scroll to the bottom of General.
- Activate the Config Editor button.
- Search for mail.openMessageBehavior.
- Double-click the preference to change its value.
The preference takes three values:
- 0: open emails in a new window each time.
- 1: open emails in a single window and replace the previous email.
- 2: open emails in tabs (default).
Now You: which of the options do you prefer, and why?
Related: Turn off tabs in Thunderbird
Wow! They broke it?
I’m using Thunderbird 52.9.1 and emails open in new windows. It it as simple as not showing the preview pane then all emails are shown in their own window