YouTube used AI to edit Shorts, but didn't tell creators about it

YouTube Shorts are being edited by AI automatically. But Google didn't bother to inform creators about it.
The issue has blown up over the past couple of weeks, with several reports pointing out that something looked wrong in videos.
BBC points out this problem may have started more than 2 months ago. Here is one thread from June 2025 that highlighted how YouTube was using AI upscaling to make the image appear look better. But the result was anything but better, it was smudgy, like an oil painting. The user said that upscaling artifacts were noticeable when you changed the video's resolution, too. This is the video in question.
Rhett Shull, a guitarist, has published a video where he outlines the problem. He showcased a comparison of Musician, Rick Beato's videos, one of which was uploaded to Instagram Reels, and one to YouTube Shorts. Though the contents of the 2 videos were the same, the image on the YouTube version looked like it was made by AI, with fake hair, skin. The shadows, and objects looked odd too, like they were plastic, or blurry. Some facial textures looked like they were modified fake because of some sharpening, smoothing effects done by the AI. It's kind of difficult to explain the hideousness, but it screams AI.
Shull also compared two of his own videos, observing their discrepancies. At one point in the video, Shull asks his wife, a professional photographer, for her opinion on the videos. She admitted it looks weird, and raised a very important question. "Will people think we are making AI videos?" This could be a legitimate concern for many YouTubers. It could affect their channels, and in turn their earnings, if viewers believed the videos were fake, and stopped watching them.
Some users allege that YouTube was doing this deliberately, to make real videos look like AI, to get people used to generative AI shorts which are currently being tested. That's just what the world needs, AI slop and real videos ruined by AI slop.
Rene Ritchie, YouTube's head of editorial and creator liaison, admitted that these videos were a result of an experiment on select YouTube Shorts is using AI to improve the video quality, and that it uses traditional machine learning. It does not use GenAI, or upscaling. This machine learning technique adds various post-processing effects like unblur, denoise, and improve clarity in videos.
YouTube has been shoving AI features in for a long time, for the better or worse, take your pick. But, AI generated videos on YouTube are a huge problem. Google did say it would prevent inauthentic AI generated videos on YouTube from being monetized. But are these rules for thee and not for me? When the platform deliberately makes a video look inferior, is that nor interfering with the artist's original work? There was no consent, and no option to opt-out of the process as far as I can tell.
Imagine you are a content creator, and you worked hard to produce a video, only to find out your face and other details in the video looked smudgy, like an AI generated video. How would that make you feel?
What a boring load of old claptrap. I can’t believe anyone would waste their time watching something like that. Nothing wrong with the video quality though.
Trying to find uses for their expensive toy lol…
All this knee-jerk anti-AI stuff in a tech blog is sad.
Neither side is good. Whether it’s good or bad that they are using AI is not that newsworthy.
AI is the new fad so it’s everywhere. Maybe the only benefit for corporations is to cut the workforce and make more money. People who are tech savvy can tell what’s AI for themselves. And it’s up to each and every one of them to decide whether they agree with it or not.
I block all Shorts from my YouTube.
Youtube should allow its users to choose non AI videos, because there are thousand of AI videos that makes nonsense, good for nothing those videos are. AI videos with artificial voices are the absolute nonsense of the pure crap Youtube site is becoming.
We had — and still have — YouTube modifying a video’s audio track original language (AI/translated audio), and now, ladies and gentlemen, YouTube’s latest interference in videos it hosts: let’s give a big hand for AI edited videos, without the consent of the authors of course (otherwise it wouldn’t be fun, would it?).
This may be specific of Google’s total lack of respect for users but I think personally that it is the illustration, a perfect example of an American tradition to modify what is natural to a look which satisfies its standards. Remakes of foreign movies, tasteless coffee because true coffee is too tough, chile con carne the American way because in Mexico it’s too hot, desert sweet wine because an adequate one to enhance meat is considered as vinegar (yep, I’ve experienced that at a rather fancy supper with the so-called elites of the town, but that was in the deep south, lands of uneducated people for most). They just can’t help it: they have to change things in the name of an as stupid as sophisticated pseudo-principle of enhancing the aesthetics. This is truly a genuine American problem.
When will Google and its Youtube dedicated staff understand that YOU DO NOT MODIFY A VIDEO YOU HOST? Either yo refuse it, either you host it AS IT IS. Artists have complained, so rightly, but artistically designed or not, you keep your hands and your AI editor off of these videos without which you’d be nothing. Users have done the work, you only host it, so keep your dreams of elaborated aesthetics for yourself. Life is not Barbie, nor pink, nor smooth, it is raw by nature and should remain raw when expressed in whatever way, with whatever qualifications, talents, intentions. If I want red skies and blue grass and make a video from there on, you leave it as it is. If I want a video and soundtrack to mimic the quality of the eighties’ productions, you leave it as it is. Can you dig that, YouTube?
Google, again and always, mama mia …
@Tom Hawack,
I think this is the least of YouTube’s problems.
I’ve been noticing lately on Brave on desktop the website’s contents load slower and videos begin playing with a delay sometimes. Sometimes they start instantly, on other occasions it takes between 5-10 seconds.
I’ve heard people saying that Google does this intentionally for browsers different than Google Chrome and especially if it detects that the user has some adblocking enabled.
On mobile with Brave it seems OK, so I’m guessing if I force mobile layout on desktop it might fix the problem, but I can’t be bothered that much.
The problem is that YouTube is still the most popular platform for video. I really like Rumble, because it loads faster, videos do too, but too bad that not a lot of interesting content is there to watch. Some YouTube creators have a Rumble channel and they upload on both platforms, but that’s just 1 out of 20 cases, which is not good enough.
I’m not even bothered if Google is making YouTube anti-competitive to work bad on other browsers, it bothers me how slow the pages load when the website doesn’t even have that much resource-heavy content. On powerful machines it even loads slow, I have noticed on my i7-13620H laptop different performance if I switch between Power Saving and Performance mode, but I’m not gonna keep the laptop’s fans blowing and heating just for YouTube to be better and have twice as less battery life.
It’s annoying that YouTube in the past loaded and worked much faster, now the website feels so bloated, everything looks oversized and searching for results has been made much more difficult, you have to search for what you want and then spend an extra click to select “Videos” from the filters on top and how big the thumbnails are, it makes you scroll so much just to see a few of them. The layout around 2014 was the last good one that also worked fast and things weren’t grossly oversized for whatever reason.
I have similar gripes with Android – the UI since versions 6-7 look so boring – bland colors, oversized buttons, so boring to look at and to navigate. The only good thing is it still allows you to sideload apps and has more freedom than iOS, if that was gone, there would be no reason to use Android at all.
I think that Google, like Microsoft being a monopoly, are abusing their reach and power and making their products, in terms of user experience and UI very horrible and frustrating to use. Why, I have no idea, but I’ve found at least an alternative to Windows – Linux Mint, but for YouTube I still haven’t found anything really. There are only programs like NewPipe, Grayjay and FreeTube that allow for a better experience, but I dislike the idea of being forced to use apps for services that should work just as fine on website, since that’s their main location.
Things are becoming very anti-consumer everywhere and I think something’s about to change soon as people grow more frustrated… unless the ones being frustrated are a tiny minority and nothing changes in the end.
@Allwynd, things have changed a lot indeed since the beginnings of YouTube and seem to accelerate exponentially, unless to consider we are in a transit period after which other approaches, new paradigms as everyone says now (if the word is back to fashion it may be that it is needed more than ever) will entertain a calmer pace.
I’ve abandoned viewing YouTube videos in the strict frame of the YouTube Website for years now. When I do access YouTube servers it is only in a video’s embedded requirements, so I don’t deal with all the slowness, ads etc.
Listen, I’m going to confess something, more for the sake of intellectual honesty than for that of a soul’s inclination to the Heavens: when a company develops products, services such as some of those proposed by Google, it cannot be entirely bad, unless to consider a devil’s intelligence which is irrelevant given Mephistopheles is under us, not over :) What I mean is that if I interrogate myself about why Google and myself are not the best friends (me in particular, Google quietly waits that we surrender as a male waits a lady’s refusal to be accommodated with at least a smile) … it’s all about a company as others which exaggerates in my view its Return On Investment requirements, fed by an always more in return growing faster than an always better, and at this rate bumps arise in our relationship to the company but also technically, unless to blindly approve all requisites : paid plan, no ad-blocker, if possible a (modern, recent) device and browser out of the box … you’re fit for Nirvana! But we don’t all approve or have the means for a top-notch digital environment. And then you have or not a privacy doctrine which can be more or less elaborated. I admit mine tends to sophistication, and maybe am I over-reacting. I’m not saying I am, only that the idea I possibly could be is starting to make its way in my thoughts but, given the length of a recovery together with my age I doubt I’ll change before I quit unwillingly this world!
I don’t like conflicts and even less hatred, but revolt is another area. I happen to be revolted, as us all, not by life but by what is done of it by some of us. Revolt, but never hatred, not to mention hatred is bad for our health. You can manage to get rid of hatred if it ever happens to be a natural aspect of your personality, by calling upon either intelligence or spirituality (or both), but nothing does it against revolt, because revolt is fed by injustice, and this is why administrations have always feared revolts far more than basic urban angers and riots ; social peace has no price.
Anyway, this said, we try to improve, but why have we waited so long?! When the end comes it’s amazing to notice a spectacular shift towards morality, lol.
@Tom Hawack, said,
» Life is not Barbie, nor pink, nor smooth, it is raw by nature and should remain raw when expressed in whatever way, with whatever qualifications, talents, intentions. «
I beg your pardon sir, wasn’t the Barbie movie canceled in France? Isn’t that worse than what YouTube does currently despite your criticism? Any explanation for such palliated freedom in France? Before criticizing YouTube, you should think about how a European country can ban a film filled with pink and smooth images. Not your best comment, by the way.
To Snorkel, it’s widely known the culprits that cancelled Barbie in France. However nobody is free to talk about them in Europe. You perfectly know what I meant, for sure.
@Jamie, you are spreading fake news.
1- ‘Barbie’ was not cancelled in France country-wide, in fact the film has had 6 million entries in this country. The movie has been canceled ONLY in the city of Noisy-le-Sec, north of Paris, because of violence held by fanatics. That the mayor decided to cancel the film because of this violence is deplorable and a wide majority of French inhabitants have disagreed, but this is in no way a whatever government, administration decision.
2- In Europe EVERYBODY not only is free to comment this regrettable city mayor’s decision, but actually does and has done. Europe does not have the taboos of the Anglo-Saxon culture when it comes to sexuality, we are as free as can be in this domain. Yet, there are far-right winds of puritanism together with Islamism (political Islam, not the one of my neighbors and friends) that spread hatred and violence whenever they can, and that is what happened in Noisy-le-Sec, close to Paris.
3- Anyone who is free of any form of extremism can live happily in Europe as elsewhere… as long has he/she is not confronted to barbarians. The choice is clear: civilization vs. barbarians. Spreading fake news is not a civilized attitude, doing it willingly is a barbarian attitude. I have no doubt yo are mistaking.
4- This is not the place of such debates, I do not initiate but I shall systematically answer to fake news, here as elsewhere.
Let’s pay attention to this phrase by TomHawak: “Yet, there are far-right winds of puritanism together with Islamism (political Islam, not the one of my neighbors and friends) that spread hatred and violence whenever they can, and that is what happened in Noisy-le-Sec, close to Paris.” » “political Islam, not the one of my neighbors and friends”…
Of course, your neighbors and friends are all flowers of the most beautiful sun.
Europe is sold.
@McKenzie, I’m not sure what attention anyone could pay to such an empty comment as yours; I may be one of the few given it’s a reply to mine.
Come on! Not being radical, extremist but nuanced and human doesn’t make you a saint, nor does being make you a devil. How can such a binary assertion ever have been thought?
The end of the comment is of the same flavor, “Europe is sold”. Is it? Argument if you please.
‘Paying attention’ and being ‘sold’, money terms as some leaders seem to know but those. This said, nowadays with the businessman and the tsar both being pals and both hating Europe you never know if fake news discriminating and/or manipulating Europe come from Maga or from Rashka …
To @TomHawak
You have started your reply with a complete lie:
“@Jamie, you are spreading fake news.”, that’s not true at all and you know it.
1- ‘”the movie has been canceled ONLY in the city of Noisy-le-Sec, north of Paris, because of violence held by fanatics.” Tom, where is Noisy-le-Sec? In France… Then Barbie was cancelled in France, and only in France. The rest of Europe was perfectly OK.
2- “Europe does not have the taboos of the Anglo-Saxon culture when it comes to sexuality, we are as free as can be in this domain.”, What are you talking about again, dude? You are in Europe, then what are you talking about? Are you living in other dimension? Europe is plenty of taboos dude, Barbie was cancelled in such an example of “democratic Europe”…
3- “Anyone who is free of any form of extremism can live happily in Europe as elsewhere… as long has he/she is not confronted to barbarians. ” What are you talking about, again? Don’t you have tired spreading annonying lies about Europe? Please read some news, crime has been increased an incredible 68% in Europe in the last decade. Happily living my two cents…
4- “This is not the place of such debates.”, again Tom, you started it, dude, you started it and you can’t accept you are not right in your arguments. You are always giving lessons of everything, however you are unable to see the reality of your own country nor Europe neither.
And please, just remember that Europe has zero weight in computer industry… I think that Youtube and Google has provided Europe a lot of benefits, more than Europe needs. Europe would live in the stone age if american companies left Europe at its luck alone. Cheers!
@Jamie,
First, my first comment was all about a cultural context, not political. It is your reply which turned wine into vinegar.
Fake news are easily detectable once you take the time to verify by yourself. I’ve put it on the account of your ignorance. Maybe excessively relying on AI to get notions of reality?
The rest of your comments are not arguments but plain denials, like a kid bragging “no, no, no”. But I must admit that developing arguments when there is none is a tough challenge. Unless to invent, like some chief of states do.
Come back when you’ll have but some consistency in your ideas. Or don’t given this is not the place for politics which, again, you’ve initiated. I know that some believe that everything is political, I don’t, and I don’t think that culture is or should be. I had evoked one of America’s multiple cultural aspects, only. Read the thread, take your time, no hurry. Dude.
FYI and to neutralize your mistake when you write “Then Barbie was cancelled in France, and only in France.”, a bit lengthy result of queries to give you an idea of the enormity of your assertion. And I’ll finish this surrealistic dialog with it.
The controversy surrounding the cancellation of the Barbie movie screening in Noisy-le-Sec was localized and did not result in a nationwide ban. Here are some articles that clarify this point:
– PinkNews: The article states that the mayor of Noisy-le-Sec, Olivier Sarrabeyrouse, emphasized that “Barbie has never been banned in France.” This indicates that the cancellation was specific to the local screening due to threats from a small group. [https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2025/08/15/barbie-screening-cancelled-paris-noisy-le-sec/]
– LGBTQ Nation: This article also mentions that the film was selected through a public vote and that the mayor condemned the cancellation as a form of moral censorship, reiterating that the film has not been banned in France. [https://www.lgbtqnation.com/2025/08/screening-of-barbie-movie-shut-down-by-protestors-in-france/]
– Yahoo News: The report highlights that the mayor described the situation as an attack on cultural programming and confirmed that the film had not been banned in the country. [https://malaysia.news.yahoo.com/too-fabulous-aggressive-minority-forces-020200002.html]
>>> Hope that helps, you and anyone mistaking on this regrettable issue. <<<
@Snorkel,
The film indeed was cancelled in Paris as it seems (I missed that news at the time given Barbie, whatever concept, doesn’t interest me).
For one I wasn’t aware that “Screening of “Barbie” movie had been shut down by protestors who said it promotes homosexuality” (as I read an article’s title after searching for this). Personally I disapprove such a decision which is clearly a form of moral censorship.
For two, the shut down has not been a government decision but that of a mayor in regard of the violence and hatred initiated by a group of fanatics:
“Yet another serious attack on programming that deprives families and children of a cultural event,” said French Culture Minister Rachida Dati (Les Républicains, center-right [NOTE: just like me, but who cares]). “In the past year, I have taken firm measures against these serious attacks that have become a new form of delinquency.”
For three, when I evoked Barbie I was referring to an American culture which mistakes dreams (pink or not) with life and from there on aims to consider (and to enforce by all means as it seems with Google) that transformed reality is preferable to raw life. This was and remains my explanation of YouTube’s edition of videos.
For four (44) : let us compare what is comparable. A local, a city’s decision to shut down a movie given violence and riots (whilst the government disapproves and says it) , be it regrettable, has nothing to do with Europe’s policy regarding censorship of fake news and speech of hatred and violence. Freedom is not palliated in France nor is it in Europe. It’s only that we’re facing two different concepts.
The far-right US administration considers that freedom is no longer freedom should it be limited by whatever barrier. Europe considers that there is no freedom when freedom becomes anarchic because of the refusal of any firewall. Firewalls exist, everywhere, country constitutions and laws include them. It’s only that some of us believe they shouldn’t apply when expression only is involved.
This said, and if we start the game of comparisons, here in Europe we don’t fire people for their beliefs whilst on the other side of the Atlantic, if you happen to annoy a chief of state you may get kicked off with no trial.
So you see at the end it’s all in freedom being served with respect for all or freedom serving a few on the basis of extremist policies and behaviors. That’s not the America I knew, know, but rather a martial sheriff dictating his rules as in one of those Westerns. It won’t last forever.
So, far we went from a Google’s audacity to edit users’ videos to, again, scratch a debate over freedom, one being respectful of all, the other respectful of none.