Xbox age verification in UK rolling out

Microsoft has announced that it has begun rolling out age verification for Xbox users in the UK via https://aka.ms/xboxukageverification. This process is to comply with The Online Safety Act.
Age verification is a bit of a problem in many Countries, even in the European Union. Governments want to protect the safety of children, keeping them away from harmful, inappropriate content on the internet. While that's a good idea, the process of verifying one's age poses some privacy issues. Many people also feel that this is a form of censorship.
The Verge reports that some people have managed to bypass age verification on Reddit, Discord, by using Death Stranding's photo mode. They just pointed their phone's camera at the game's protagonist, that's pretty ingenious. Others have used VPNs to trick services into thinking they are from a different Country. But such tricks don't work with every verification service, apparently it doesn't with Xbox.
How does age verification affect Xbox users in the UK?
Don't worry, your game library is not affected by these requirements. Xbox users who don't verify their age by early 2026, will not be able to access some social features. You'll still be able to use voice and text communication with friends, party functionality and game invites, and user generated content (including Activity Feed). You will not be able to access Custom Clubs, or Look for Groups, access Discord, or broadcast gameplay to Twitch.
How do you verify your age on Xbox?
Microsoft uses Yoti as its "trusted age verification partner." Users who are at least 18 years of age can go to Microsoft's website, https://aka.ms/XboxUKAgeVerification. You will be asked to sign in to your account, after which you can verify your age by taking a selfie, scan a government-issued ID such as your driver's license or passport, a mobile number or a credit card check.
Microsoft says that a live photo (selfie) or ID documents that you submit to it will be encrypted and deleted after use. The mobile number is checked through your carrier, while your credit card is just used to verify your age (no charges). Both types of data are not stored or shared beyond the initial check. Refer to the official documentation for more details.
Microsoft says it plans to roll out age verification processes to more regions in the future, but it's not clear which Countries will get the requirements. This is definitely a cause for concern.
What do you think about age verification rules?
Guess what. You now have to submit your biometric and Government ID to listen to Spotify. Otherwise, your account will be eventually cancelled. I guess Rap and Hip-Hop became dangerous for children, or they are afraid of podcasters, which is more likely?. Utopia at its finest.
There’s a lot of draconian stuff on the way in the Western world under the pretense of “protecting vulnerable” and what not, a large scale surveillance system and digital panopticon prison limiting ordinary citizens ability to speak out and resist mischief by the global cabal, otherwise what will happen is people will self sensor themselves.
Uploading a photo of ones face is biometric data, and there’s no guarantees it will not be saved by some MITM actor even if it will be saved by Reddit and similar for short time, just like Snowden revealed already years ago how some internet traffic is wire tapped in US, and for certain in much of the Western world, and several others included as well.
Unfortunately the grey area between safe and unsafe content is quite wide
From this article: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cj4ep1znk4zo
David Greene, civil liberties director at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, said the UK’s Online Safety Act was a “real tragedy”.
“UK users can no longer use the internet without having to provide their papers, as it were,” he said, adding that he was disappointed websites like Reddit were not legally challenging the law.
EFF do have a lot of articles concerning several privacy issues, I haven’t visited EFF for a long time and can only say that the articles on their web site have exploded in size concerning privacy issues so it’s a worrying trend we have seen for past several years
https://www.eff.org/
Microsoft is not doing this for any good reson it is only to increase the amount of personal information/data they can harvest.
Microsoft actually does not have a choice. Unless all big services join together and resist against UK censorship, none of them can fight alone. UK is willing to kill everybody’s access to Internet to promote censorship. Australia is on the way to the same situation.
What censorship? As explained on [https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/online-safety-act] :
“The Online Safety Act 2023 (the Act) protects children and adults online. It puts a range of new duties on social media companies and search services, giving them legal duties to protect their users from illegal content and content harmful to children. The Act gives providers new duties to implement systems and processes to reduce risks their services are used for illegal activity, and to take down illegal content when it does appear.”
You’d have a kid discovering the Kama Sutra (at best), rape (at worst) before he’s even had is first kiss, you’d agree? You’d consider your kid is facing censorship? You’d have a daughter killed by words of hatred on a social website before killing herself with a rope, you’d consider your daughter is facing censorship?
Yelling “Censorship! Censorship! Censorship” when the aim is to protect whilst forgetting that true censorship exists elsewhere, for instance when you get brought to jail only because you’ve attended a demonstration with blank signs, no slogan, nothing but silent protestation : THAT is censorship, state censorship.
For crying out loud, stop using words inappropriately. The fashion followed by sheep is to consider that any imposed limit whatever the reasons is an attack on their glorified rights. Truth is that given the irresponsibility linked to greed of a few but powerful when they are social websites is a most valid argument to impose some rules. In an ideal world, no rules, no police, no army. World is not ideal is it? So rules we need. PERIOD.
This is censorship in its purest form. Russia does not “censor” YouTube either, but everybody in Russia started to use VPN as soon as “technical limitations” appeared. And guess what happened in the UK? 700% increase in searches for VPNs.
But you believe in honest governments, right? So why you have to show your ID if you want to play game, post on X or Reddit and edit on Wikipedia? (not my favorite sites, but it does not diminish the problem). Now UK is sending legal letters to all video hosting sites including YouTube and Rumble telling them they will have conformed to UK laws, or they will be fined 10% of global profit. How long before Amazon Prime, Netflix or HBO Max will be the next. There is also 6 month review in this bill that if people start using VPNs too much, VPNs many be banned in the UK. Welcome to the world where you have to give Government ID to any website or service.
Australia is expecting to pass a similar bill. Collective Shout asswipes recently forced payment processors to delete all adult themed games from multiple gaming services. If you do not see censorship coming over to Western Internet, you live in happy oblivion. If Governments and monopolist corporations can take little bite and there are no response, they will bigger byte next year. It always starts: let’s protect the weak and young. It always ends up in open revolt or tyranny. I am not surprised when anti-immigrant protest happening in UK: it’s always “ultra-right”. UK sold off all of its Industries and sports teams, but there was an attempt to sell some media corporations, suddenly it is too much. UK knows that it has to control their citizens. So Government adjacent media will never be sold and now they will try to control Internet. Australia is exactly in the same boat: one for one. No wonder they are copying the UK bill.
And about protecting children. Who decided that children Internet use should not be monitored by parents? I remember a time when parents allowed children to use Internet only in their presence in the living room. And maybe graduate to independent use after a few years of explaining all potential pitfalls. We outsourced children to schools where teachers are overwhelmed or do not care and open Internet. Soon we will outsource them to Governments and Government approved corporations.
@boris, perhaps agreeing on the definition of ‘censorship’ will avoid focusing on the word rather than on on its context, legitimacy, implications.
Censorship:
Usually means: suppression of information or expression.
More precisely : the use of state or group power to control freedom of expression or press, such as passing laws to prevent undesirable media from being published or propagated.
From there on, OK, the word applies as well to the ‘The Online Safety Act 2023 (the Act)’ as it does to totalitarian regimes which forbid any form of free speech and protest.
What differentiates those who refuse any form of censorship from others who consider that in certain circumstances it is legitimate and even imperative is perhaps that the former focus on a principle, ‘intellectually’ so to say, when others focus on the implications of a ‘Freedom 360°, 24/7’ in given circumstances, circumstances they consider to prevail on the principle.
Law, legality, constitutionally and by its texts impose rights and duties, with nuances from one country to another but with a common basis when it comes to fundamentals : do not kill, do not harm. These terms are mostly accepted because they translate what appears to be common sens and universal consciousness. Should they be refused and stealing, hurting would be considered as an attempt to one’s rights : this is the argument deployed by those who are obsessed by their rights but not by their duties.
I think a comparison with censorship is a valid one. What are the implications of one’s free speech, images, videos when these may hurt the weak ones and especially children? Either banishment, either censorship, either a controlled censorship in that it does not strictly censor but does in consideration of the audience : hence, in our case, an age verification: In the dialectical these-antithesis-synthesis I think this is the closest we can get to the best of two worlds: freedom and protection.
Of course an important argument, and valid IMO, when it comes to freedom with limits, is that whatever has been the legislator’s precautions to fine-tune his decision, an administration may very well deploy a biased argumentation to have the legislator’s decision apply to its own advantage, i.e. ‘National security’ to legitimate decisions and transparency when these are not concerned (or rather when they appear later on as not having been concerned given they may happen to be, factually, concerned).
Fine-tuning a law is the hardest thing to do when the aim is to conciliate rights and duties of all.
All that I can say at this point without deploying extra lines of philosophy, politics, sociology and even psychology is this: should I have to choose between anyone’s safety (and a kid’s in particular) and my rights to publish/discover anything incompatible with the former, that I’d privilege safety, because safety, IMO and in a pyramid of values will always be positioned above whatever freedom.
This said, of course your second comment about parents’ duties is obvious yet I’m not sure it is in anyway more feasible than applying a law’s censorship : none are bullet-proof.
My conclusion, honestly, at this time, and given that even if I do approve censorship in the terms I described above, I remain skeptical generally speaking on the effectiveness of any process based on an attempt to limit freedom’s full expression. Hence I consider that any form of imposed citizen’s duty is a work-around a citizen’s inability to live and let live in terms of moral codes and aesthetics : humanity needs legal frames, most unfortunately, still needs should it ever progress towards the summits of human consciousness.
PS
And how about a much simpler solution than forcing IDs. Do not sell children under 14 or 16 smartphones or tablets unless it is bought by a parent. Maybe allow simple photo app and Map app and so on with no sharing. And no possibility to install browser or social apps. Social apps and porn are dangerous to child’s mind. So if you buy them a phone with social apps as a parent, be legally and financially responsible for their use. Do not push responsibly on everybody else. And if you buy or pay monthly bills for a child’s phone, and you are not a parent, make it a real crime.
I understand there are technical holes in this argument, but it can be improved. And parent will have to learn some technology and be able to periodically scan content of the child’s phone/tablet. Not just look at the row of innocent icons.
At the end, we do not force IDs on everything else because somebody might die. Restaurants do not force IDs because somebody might have an allergy to certain foods. Can you imagine going to a Restaurant and not be able to eat until you produce medical ID that you do not have peanut allergy?
There are few places that IDs are necessary: to communicate with policemen, to vote, to drive, to buy a gun, to visit a hospital or flight on the plane. But I never want to live in the world where it is necessary to give ID to look up information or to watch a movie or to play a game.