Comments on: External Hard Drives: How do I Choose Which One to Buy

By: Ace Winget

Ace Winget — Wed, 27 Oct 2010 17:18:27 +0000

Thanks for the article. These are some good tips. I think external hard drives are great for how flexible they are.

By: Yonatan Amir

Yonatan Amir — Thu, 06 Aug 2009 18:56:26 +0000

In the case of larger 3.5″ drives, the power connector should be standard so it’s easy to replace the power supply should it fail or get lost.

By: Snowdog

Snowdog — Thu, 06 Aug 2009 01:00:20 +0000

I’ve had issues w/ Seagate Freeagent drives on Linux systems. The primary problem is the power saving spin-down that occurs after about 15 min. This can cause access delays, particularly when attempting to use cron jobs for automated backup.

Workarounds include using sdparm, or a succession of “ls” commands (2 or 3) prior to the commencement of rsync backups to ensure the drive is “awake” prior to attempting file copying.

By: Pawel

Pawel — Wed, 05 Aug 2009 12:32:53 +0000

I use Seagate with few problems on a XP.
It was Plug and Play really.
Very nice look.
Good luck in your decision.

By: wabbity1

wabbity1 — Wed, 05 Aug 2009 03:38:43 +0000

Another important feature is the ability to spin down the HD (but
keep the USB connection to the computer alive) during periods
of inactivity. Some drives can (most major brands’ enclosures
with HD included), so can’t (nearly all DIY).

By: Chris

Chris — Wed, 05 Aug 2009 00:17:30 +0000

I see that you say that you didn’t include WD among your options because they seem to be more expensive, but perhaps they might end up being more reliable, too. I own three different WD external HDs, one of which is three years old and one of which I use daily and really acts as an external drive for my computer, and I haven’t had a failure on any of them yet.

By: Beecher Bowers

Beecher Bowers — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 19:50:20 +0000

I’ve had poor luck with Seagate FreeAgent drives. Multiple failures with different drives. I had to run my last one on an ice pack just to get the data moved off prior to returning it.

http://beecherbowers.com/2009/05/08/dead-or-failing-seagate-freeagent-external-disk-errors/

By: Steve

Steve — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 18:53:26 +0000

I have 2 Seagate Freeagent Extremes 1.5 TB Externals. Both drives have
been very unreliable with one crashed and the other on the way.
I bought both drives in the past 2 months. The USB interface woks
OK when the drive(s) work at all. The firewire interface may work
1 out of 10 times so it is useless. This is the 2nd set of Seagate
external drives I’ve purchased and in both cases, both sets have
become useless in just a few months. I also have a set of 500 GB WD
external USB drives a few years old where 1 drive still works and the
other has crashed. All of my external drives are used basically like
my internal drive with little physical stress of movement of the entire
enclosure and drive
I also have a 1.5 TB SATA Seagate internal only about 2 months old and
so far that drive has been trouble free. Still, Seagate drive failure rate has been much to high, I don’t plan to purchase any more Seagate drives.

Steve

By: Matt

Matt — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 18:46:22 +0000

I’m taking a slightly different tack here, so forgive me if I go astray.

The thing I really want you to understand is that anything you get will fail eventually. Based on how you started your question (an alternative to burning data), I’m thinking that what you’re really looking for here is something like an archival system, which is actually a really difficult problem to tackle. There’s a reason why businesses pay big bucks for off site backups and archival systems.

IMO, all the prepackaged, external drives that run from USB power on the market today are pretty crappy, which is why you see mixed reviews. If it were me, I’d save my pennies and set up a nice little NAS box with RAID that can just sit in a corner and play nicely, have some decent backup capabilities and potentially be networked and therefore be “portable” wherever there’s an internet connection.

My $.002

By: Cheryl

Cheryl — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 17:45:08 +0000

WD is something I considered but they seem to be more expensive without really offering anything different from the other two. That’s why I didn’t include it.

Another brand I looked at was Maxtor.

By: Rarst

Rarst — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 16:53:28 +0000

Multiple OS support
Most of external media uses same drivers, not an issue with any modern OS.

Partitioning
Unless you are going to mess with OS on it, single partition is fine (as for me).

Durability
External hard drives have life span of regular drive being moved around. If it is going to sit on the table – it will live as long. If you are going to throw it into walls – drastically less.

As for what I use – 1.8″ 80Gb Prestigio Pocket Drive 2 (Toshiba HDD inside). It is expensive toy but I wanted something very small and it is. Quite reliable so far, considering amount of torture my external media gets (I kill good flash drive with overuse every year or so).

By: kevinn

kevinn — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 16:51:08 +0000

I’m more trusting with WD drives. I have two WD Passport Essentials 320gb each, and they’re running fine.

They’re preformatted to FAT32, so no problems for Linux or Windows to use them out of the box. Still, note about the 4gb limit on files. Partition them all you want to their own respective filesystems – depends on your use.

I’m also thinking about getting another one or probably the desktop versions of the drive for a file dump.

By: yosh

yosh — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 16:37:21 +0000

i have to 320gig seagate for awhile, its very slim so noting in the way of shock absorption. its not rugerized by any mean.

it work well and gets its power via usb, so some notebooks ports dont have enough juice for it, it then goes beep for a while until you are sure its brivcked and get it to another port.

By: Marc

Marc — Tue, 04 Aug 2009 16:12:06 +0000

Seagate have a history of premature failure just after warranty, just like all manufacturers they correct their problems eventually but Seagate has had a very bad customer for this.

Tanscend, hard to tell, depend on who makes them, where and with which specs, usually Fujitsu makes them so they are relatively reliable but are slower than most others.

MyBooks from WD have a very low failure rate and WD warranty is hard to beat. They even replaced one of mine even if it was out of warranty. I personally would go for a WD but one thta has less than 1tb, like a 500gigs, they have been around a long time and have been debugged.