Comments on: Windows Vista SD Card Problem http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/ A technology blog covering software, mobile phones, gadgets, security, the Internet and other relevant areas. Mon, 13 Oct 2008 07:31:22 +0000 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.6.2 By: Lisa http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-406436 Lisa Sun, 13 Jul 2008 16:26:11 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-406436 Hi, I'm having problems too, but they are different than everyone else's. I have a month old HP dv9700t notebook computer running Vista Home Premium 64-bit, with a built-in multi-function card reader and I also have a USB Edge All-in-1 external card reader. I have two 2GB SD cards: a SanDisk Ultra and a Prospec (Calumet's brand). Both are used in my digital camera. The internal card reader in the notebook reads both cards fine. It appears to be a Ricoh device. When I try to use the external USB Edge card reader, which works fine and is extremely fast on my Windows XP Pro notebook, the system sees the reader and the card, but it doesn't work right. It takes many seconds for Auto-Play to come up, many more seconds before I can open the directories, and then Vista keeps rereading the card over and over when I scroll through directory entries. It can't seem to obtain all of the data. It takes forever to show dates of the files. If I try to open files or copy them off the card it either hangs, or errors out. I've been unable to get a solution to this problem so far. Edge says they have a 64-bit Vista system that works fine with the reader I have. So it does seem that there is an issue with the driver configuration on some of these notebooks. I'm trying Microsoft support, but getting nowhere. Getting ready to try HP support. This is ticking me off because the external reader is so much faster than the internal readers. There is no reason I shouldn't be able to use it. I am running Service Pack 1, but it was preinstalled by HP. I even tried reinstalling my system from the Recovery partition and that didn't help. I don't have any 1GB cards to try in my external reader, to see if this is only a problem with 2GB or larger cards. They are probably cheap, maybe I should go get one and try it. This is very similar behavior to what I saw on my old notebook that can't handle 2GB cards in the internal reader. Lisa Hi,

I’m having problems too, but they are different than everyone else’s. I have a month old HP dv9700t notebook computer running Vista Home Premium 64-bit, with a built-in multi-function card reader and I also have a USB Edge All-in-1 external card reader. I have two 2GB SD cards: a SanDisk Ultra and a Prospec (Calumet’s brand). Both are used in my digital camera. The internal card reader in the notebook reads both cards fine. It appears to be a Ricoh device. When I try to use the external USB Edge card reader, which works fine and is extremely fast on my Windows XP Pro notebook, the system sees the reader and the card, but it doesn’t work right. It takes many seconds for Auto-Play to come up, many more seconds before I can open the directories, and then Vista keeps rereading the card over and over when I scroll through directory entries. It can’t seem to obtain all of the data. It takes forever to show dates of the files. If I try to open files or copy them off the card it either hangs, or errors out. I’ve been unable to get a solution to this problem so far. Edge says they have a 64-bit Vista system that works fine with the reader I have. So it does seem that there is an issue with the driver configuration on some of these notebooks. I’m trying Microsoft support, but getting nowhere. Getting ready to try HP support. This is ticking me off because the external reader is so much faster than the internal readers. There is no reason I shouldn’t be able to use it. I am running Service Pack 1, but it was preinstalled by HP. I even tried reinstalling my system from the Recovery partition and that didn’t help.

I don’t have any 1GB cards to try in my external reader, to see if this is only a problem with 2GB or larger cards. They are probably cheap, maybe I should go get one and try it. This is very similar behavior to what I saw on my old notebook that can’t handle 2GB cards in the internal reader.

Lisa

]]> By: RayHend http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-394892 RayHend Fri, 04 Jul 2008 16:26:06 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-394892 Ok, so what's the answer with the issue? Is there any way to use the SD cards with Vista? Funny thing for me is that, until last night, I never had a problem with this, and I've had my laptop for almost a year. Ok, so what’s the answer with the issue? Is there any way to use the SD cards with Vista?

Funny thing for me is that, until last night, I never had a problem with this, and I’ve had my laptop for almost a year.

]]> By: voytec http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-383461 voytec Wed, 25 Jun 2008 17:09:18 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-383461 It is the reader which makes the difference. Sandisk MicroMate reads any size under Vista home without that stupid formatting issue. My other "no name" multi readers read anything but SD cards under Vista as you know. Funny that this same readers are working fine with XP. It is the reader which makes the difference.
Sandisk MicroMate reads any size under Vista home without that stupid formatting issue.
My other “no name” multi readers read anything but SD cards under Vista as you know.
Funny that this same readers are working fine with XP.

]]> By: Matthias http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-374580 Matthias Wed, 18 Jun 2008 08:27:36 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-374580 I have a Dell M1530 notebook with an integrated card reader. Under Vista I cannot use this internal reader (with either a 2GB or a 64MB(!)) card. However, when I connect an external card reader to a USB port, I can read the cards without any problem! So its either a strange Windows bug or its Dell's fault... I have a Dell M1530 notebook with an integrated card reader. Under Vista I cannot use this internal reader (with either a 2GB or a 64MB(!)) card. However, when I connect an external card reader to a USB port, I can read the cards without any problem! So its either a strange Windows bug or its Dell’s fault…

]]> By: Joop http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-350414 Joop Sat, 24 May 2008 21:08:15 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-350414 Will add some info to the confusion. Laptop running Vista Home Basic with external card readers (2). Sandisk 2GB card. When using no. 1 card reader, HAMA - USB 2.0, card is shown. It's also possible to format the card on 2 GB. When using no. 2 card reader, chinese make, get the message the card has to be formatted. When trying to format only 1 GB is possible. When cancelling the format a message formatting is not possible; check the card reader / drivers. Will add some info to the confusion.
Laptop running Vista Home Basic with external card readers (2). Sandisk 2GB card.
When using no. 1 card reader, HAMA - USB 2.0, card is shown. It’s also possible to format the card on 2 GB.
When using no. 2 card reader, chinese make, get the message the card has to be formatted. When trying to format only 1 GB is possible.
When cancelling the format a message formatting is not possible; check the card reader / drivers.

]]> By: fu53b0x http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-342619 fu53b0x Thu, 15 May 2008 18:49:15 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-342619 This is total BS. My 512Mb CD card is not recognised on my laptop. Everything else appears to work (I have had Vista for a week..) I'm just gonna boot to Linux from USB key so I can send family pictures to some friends However, M$ have removed a *LOT* of programming functions from Office 2007 (simple, everyday type *useful* code) 'Fun' Billy (and muppets) are in full effect... This is total BS. My 512Mb CD card is not recognised on my laptop. Everything else appears to work (I have had Vista for a week..)

I’m just gonna boot to Linux from USB key so I can send family pictures to some friends

However, M$ have removed a *LOT* of programming functions from Office 2007 (simple, everyday type *useful* code)

‘Fun’ Billy (and muppets) are in full effect…

]]> By: Dante http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-340971 Dante Wed, 14 May 2008 00:39:50 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-340971 Ok, for those of you who has this problem: I've found the answer finally. I went out and bought a whole bunch of USB card readers (ranging from US$5 to US$50 each). I've found that the card reader who had paid Microsoft for their new and improved Vista SD driver, works with Vista. Those who remained using the generic SD config will NOT work with Windows Vista. Apparently, Microsoft have decided to set a whole new SD standard all on their own. Ok, for those of you who has this problem: I’ve found the answer finally. I went out and bought a whole bunch of USB card readers (ranging from US$5 to US$50 each). I’ve found that the card reader who had paid Microsoft for their new and improved Vista SD driver, works with Vista. Those who remained using the generic SD config will NOT work with Windows Vista. Apparently, Microsoft have decided to set a whole new SD standard all on their own.

]]> By: Dusters16 http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-340137 Dusters16 Tue, 13 May 2008 08:09:11 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-340137 I have a Dell XPS Gen 2 notebook, which came with XP, but I have happily ran Vista since Beta 2. I have only an SD card reader and have used 2gb, 3gb, and now 4gb of readyboost, and i also have an 8gb sd that goes to my canon sd750 camera. i just swap the readyboost sd card with the 8gb camera one when i need to transfer pics. sooo.... everything has worked perfect for me concerning this issue. I have a Dell XPS Gen 2 notebook, which came with XP, but I have happily ran Vista since Beta 2. I have only an SD card reader and have used 2gb, 3gb, and now 4gb of readyboost, and i also have an 8gb sd that goes to my canon sd750 camera. i just swap the readyboost sd card with the 8gb camera one when i need to transfer pics.

sooo…. everything has worked perfect for me concerning this issue.

]]> By: Starboykb http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-339838 Starboykb Tue, 13 May 2008 01:04:28 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-339838 one of my customers actually having the sd card 1gb when transferring using 'send to'and crush the whole desktop in Vista home basic. The microsoft did asked for the update but it was already patches and still experience same problem. one of my customers actually having the sd card 1gb when transferring using ’send to’and crush the whole desktop in Vista home basic. The microsoft did asked for the update but it was already patches and still experience same problem.

]]> By: Dante http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-339077 Dante Mon, 12 May 2008 13:34:02 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-339077 Funny thing is, Vista will recognize a 2 gig SD card if it's plugged into your PDA and synced through Mobile Sync. But the same Vista machine will ignore the same 2 gig SD card if plugged into a card reader. Funny thing is, Vista will recognize a 2 gig SD card if it’s plugged into your PDA and synced through Mobile Sync. But the same Vista machine will ignore the same 2 gig SD card if plugged into a card reader.

]]> By: Fluffy Llama http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-338919 Fluffy Llama Mon, 12 May 2008 09:59:57 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-338919 Wife has same problem with Vista Premium on an Acer Aspire. Has problems reading any cards, inc 2gb. Think it has been ok since SP1, not sure. Her fix was reinstall drivers just about every time she needed to use the reader... The other issue I noticed she has was audio squelching and not playing. Noticed there are heaps of people with that problem too but no fix... Luckily I run XP :P Wife has same problem with Vista Premium on an Acer Aspire. Has problems reading any cards, inc 2gb. Think it has been ok since SP1, not sure. Her fix was reinstall drivers just about every time she needed to use the reader… The other issue I noticed she has was audio squelching and not playing. Noticed there are heaps of people with that problem too but no fix… Luckily I run XP :P

]]> By: Kavin http://www.ghacks.net/2008/05/12/windows-vista-sd-card-problem/#comment-338833 Kavin Mon, 12 May 2008 07:35:10 +0000 http://www.ghacks.net/?p=4095#comment-338833 I am running Vista Business edition on my Laptop. I have both a SD card reader in-built into the laptop as well as using an external card reader. All my SD (Normal SD and Mini) cards are about 2GB and above. I don't have such problems on any of my card readers. I have another 2 machines that are running the same config with no problems. It could be an OEM driver issue rather than a Vista issue. I am running Vista Business edition on my Laptop. I have both a SD card reader in-built into the laptop as well as using an external card reader. All my SD (Normal SD and Mini) cards are about 2GB and above. I don’t have such problems on any of my card readers. I have another 2 machines that are running the same config with no problems.
It could be an OEM driver issue rather than a Vista issue.

]]>